In depth - rank the person above you

[XElite109]

Power: 2 Your movements are pretty weak

power =/= movements, i got the powah

You and me both XD

[Gary]

for waff


Flow: 8
Easing: 8
Spacing: 7
Realism: 5
Power: 6
Physics: 6
3D: 7
Effects: 7
Stick making: 15
Detail of animation: 8
Cinematics: 5

Overall Rank: Med Inter

[tuna]

Flow: 9
Easing: 9
Spacing: 9
Realism: -1
Power: 5
Physics: wat
3D: never seen you do it
Effects: 5 idk
Stick making: 3 they're pretty basic
Detail of animation: 2
Cinematics: 5

Overall Rank: High inters

[Amir]

Flow: 8 You have it pretty well
Easing: 5 You definitely need to ease more, sometimes when you finish a movement so you just stop it and it doesn't look so fluid
Spacing: 9 Good job
Realism: 4 Most of your animations are very unrealistick but that's not a problem
Power: 10 You're great at it
Physics: 6 It's okay most of the time but it can be off at times
3D: 6 I've seen some 3D angels and movements from you but they aren't always look good
Effects: 7 Sometimes your effects can work really well in your animations but you almost don't use effects in your animations
Stick making: 0 Never seen you make any detailed stick or something, you use a lot in the default stickman
Detail of animation: 7 I liked your rain animation it was pretty detailed but most of your animations are basic and without backgrounds
Cinematics: 8 Your DDC preview looked very interesting, great angels and camera movements, you can be very good at that

Overall Rank: Low Intermediate

[XElite109]

Flow: 9
Easing: 9
Spacing: 9
Realism: -1
Power: 5
Physics: wat
3D: never seen you do it
Effects: 5 idk
Stick making: 3 they're pretty basic
Detail of animation: 2
Cinematics: 5

Overall Rank: High inters

That fucking negative 1 lmao

[The Black Mamba]

Amir

Flow: 7
Easing: 6
Spacing: 8
Realism: 0
Power: 9
Physics: 3
3D: 0 never seen it
Effects: 7
Stick making: 0, I don't know which sticks are your's in your animations
Detail of animation: 7
Cinimatics: 8

Overall: Low Intermediate

[Horsie]

Flow: 9
Easing: 9
Spacing: 9
Realism: -1
Power: 5
Physics: wat
3D: never seen you do it
Effects: 5 idk
Stick making: 3 they're pretty basic
Detail of animation: 2
Cinematics: 5

Overall Rank: High inters

That fucking negative 1 lmao

ahahha :D

[Cressel]

@The Black Mamba
Flow:7
Easing:9
Spacing:7
Realism:9
Power:6
Physics:10
3D: Don't think I've seen much of 3d from you.
Effects: 6 they're pretty simple but effective really. You don't overuse them which is great
Stick making: 10 Love your work man
Detail of animation: 8
Cinematics:8

Overall Rank:Med Intermediate

[XElite109]

Flow:9
Easing:7
Spacing:8
Realism:4
Power:8
Physics:6
3D:5 hmm well you've done a few angles but not much 3d movements but i think that's under cinematics
Effects: 7
Stick making: 6
Detail of animation: 8
Cinematics:8

Overall Rank:Med Vet

[Horsie]

Flow:9
Easing:8
Spacing:6
Realism:7
Power:5
Physics:7
3D:8 u got awesome 3d combos man
Effects: didnt see any
Stick making: idk 2
Detail of animation: 5
Cinematics: wat

Overall Rank:low vetto

[Echo]

Flow: 9 Dat flow
Easing: 8 Dat easing
Spacing: 10 Dat spacing
Realism: 5 Maybe if your style wasn't so fluid and smooth the number would go up but I think your good like you are atm.
Power: 5 Looks awesome with all the effects.
Physics: 5 I don't see you make jumps or anything like that in your animations so idk.
3D: 7 You do it pretty well.
Effects: 10 Because ... magic.
Stick making: 10 You are really good.
Detail of animation: 10 Daaayum!
Cinematics: Haven't seen much from you actually.

Overall Rank: Medium-Veteran

[H bomb]

Echo

Flow: 6.5 -can become abrupt at times from occasional easing problems
Easing: 5 -sometimes is abrupt
Spacing: 8 - great spacing!
Realism: 6.5 - floppy at times, but the physics help add to your realism
Power: 7 - pretty powerful actually
Physics: 9 - nearly spot on
3D: 6 - haven't seen much, but from what I have seen it can look unrealistic. Try adding perspective to your 3d
Effects: 6 -simple but nicely executed :)
Stick making: 6 - some of your sticks are basic but cool
Detail of animation: 4 - gotta work on more detail man
Cinematics: 5 - make your animations super epic, with more camera angles etc.

Overall Rank: med inter

[Jojishi]

H bomb

Flow: 8/10
Easing: 9/10
Spacing: 8.5/10
Realism: 6.5/10
Power: 9/10
Physics: 7/10
3D: 8.5/10
Effects: 8/10
Stick making: 6/10
Detail of animation: 9/10
Cinematics: 9.5/10

Total score: 89/100

Spoiler:

Formula:
There are 12 ranks in total, so:
100 (maximum score possible) / 12 = Each individual rank score
= 8.3
Score / r = rank placement
89 / 8.3 = 10.7

1 = Low Beginner
2 = Medium Beginner
3 = High Beginner
and so on...

10.7 = Low Elite, almost bordering on Medium Elite

On second thought, this probably isn't the best system. Specific areas need more weight given to them (detail, 3D, etc.) and ranks shouldn't be evenly distributed as I've demonstrated here. Oh well. :/

[Erif]

You didn't make a thread yet D:
Guess I'll check on Animator.net

Flow: 9/10
Easing: 10/10
Spacing: 10/10
Realism: 8/10
Power: 20/10
Physics: 9/10
3D: 9/10
Effects: 9/10
Stick making: 8/10
Detail of animation: 8/10
Cinematics: 10/10

Overall Rank: ve-lite

[H bomb]

You didn't make a thread yet D:
Guess I'll check on Animator.net

Flow: 9/10
Easing: 10/10
Spacing: 10/10
Realism: 8/10
Power: 20/10
Physics: 9/10
3D: 9/10
Effects: 9/10
Stick making: 8/10
Detail of animation: 8/10
Cinematics: 10/10

Overall Rank: ve-lite

Um.. dude
Also guys don't exaggerate the ranking either, like remember a 10 is perfect. Giving someone over two or three 10's nearly makes them elite regardless. Think about your ranking and decide wether it really is legit.
Jojishi ranked properly because he didn't exaggerate any of his ranks. Just keep that in mind. Also look at Jojishi's equation. I put it on the front page :)

Anyways,
Flow: 7/10
Easing: 6.5/10
Spacing: 7/10
Realism: 5/10
Power: 7/10
Physics: 5/10
3D: 6.5/10
Effects: 4/10
Stick making: ??? (don't know which sticks are yours haha)
Detail of animation: 3/10
Cinematics:6/10

Overall Rank: med-high inter