Collect or Die Game Icon

[SIFTER]

For the past few month, I've been animating for a game which most of you already know, and we're now at the icon creation stage. Me and the developer have been experimenting a bit with the designs and came up with different versions as you can see, and we'd really, really, realllly, love to know your opinion as to which version do you like best and would look good on mobile devices.

Do bear in mind we need feedback as fast as possible. If you can't really comment, just click on the poll above.

[Cressel]

I'd say go for something cleaner less smudging and splats and effects everywhere. I mean D could work but it's still smudgy.

[Memphis]

All of them (except maybe D) look rather amateurish and don't follow the K.I.S.S principle. Do bear that in mind, keep it simple and effective.

[Daniël]

I think this would be easier to judge if you show pictures where its implemented instead or just the logo's. Gives a much better idea.

[SIFTER]

I've changed how the icon based on the feedback.